The match finished 1-1 after 90 minutes, and 2-2 after 120 minutes, with the Magpies winning 4-3 on spot-kicks.
Here are our reporter Liam Norcliffe’s player ratings from Wembley...
13. Joe Quigley 7
Came on for the tiring Dallas and ran his socks off. He actually had a chance to win it in normal time just after Notts had equalised but he was denied by a last-ditch block. He put himself about and made a nuisance of himself. Also scored in the shootout. Photo: Eddie Keogh
14. Tim Akinola 7
Replaced Mandeville and played slightly out of position on the right wing. He gave Town some fresh legs and he was able to get them up the pitch. He played a part in Dobra’s goal, but also failed to stop the cross for Notts’ second equaliser. Photo: Catherine Ivill
15. Laurence Maguire 7
Came on for Dobra in extra-time to help tighten up the left flank and did a fine job. Scored in the shootout. Photo: Tina Jenner